h/t to Henry Reich on Google+
Showing posts with label Basic Science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Basic Science. Show all posts
February 13, 2012
Basic Rocket Science
Rocket science may not be as hard as you think. Check out this video to learn about how rocket propulsion works:
h/t to Henry Reich on Google+
h/t to Henry Reich on Google+
Posted by
Ali Marie
Basic Rocket Science
2012-02-13T11:09:00-06:00
Ali Marie
Basic Science|Physics|
Comments
Labels:
Basic Science,
Physics
October 3, 2011
Beauty and Science: The Sagan and Feynman Series
There can be something almost magical about the universe as revealed by science. Few human beings in recent time have expressed this as well as Carl Sagan and Richard Feynman. I stumbled upon this video series the other day and was blown away. Enjoy.
Posted by
Anonymous
Beauty and Science: The Sagan and Feynman Series
2011-10-03T07:24:00-05:00
Anonymous
Art|Basic Science|Communicating Science|Space|What is Science?|
Comments
Labels:
Art,
Basic Science,
Communicating Science,
Space,
What is Science?
April 13, 2011
Religion and Politics in the Science Classroom
Ever since the Scope's Monkey Trials in 1925, there's been a political debate raging about the teaching of creationism and evolution in the science class. There's a lot of claims flying about: "Teach the Controversy", "Evolution is just a theory", "Intelligent Design is a science too!" Thus, so far this year, 7 different states have proposed bills that directly attack the teaching of evolution and other sciences.
As I mentioned before, this is hardly a new problem. Anti-evolution legislation is proposed every few years, and we've discussed it before. Every time, the National Center for Science Education presents its solid stance that evolution is a science and is fundamental in understanding biology; creationism, however, is not a science and has no place in the science classroom. Normally, this is enough to prevent the bill from being passed.
This year, however, there's more of a problem. In Tennessee, an anti-evolution (and anti-global warming) bill passed in the House of Representatives. It aims to let teachers "question" the sciences, and proposes they teach the alternatives. They fall into the trap I hear a lot, that "evolution is just a theory." This is not true in any sense. Evolution is a fact; we know for certain that animals change over time. We've watched it happen. The theory is Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection, which was accepted by the scientific community over a century ago. There is zero controversy among the scientists; the "controversy" is only created by political and religious groups.
It's this made-up controversy that causes around 60% of high school biology teachers to be wishy-washy, at best, with the teaching of evolution. Many of these are not creationists themselves (although, unfortunately, some are). However, it's easier to play it safe and avoid the issue than deal with unhappy parents or school boards. Less than 30% of science teachers are willing to take the necessary strong stance that evolution is a scientific fact, and deserved to be taught as the central tenant of biology that it is.
I do think that religion can be taught in schools... in a comparative religions class. Single religions can even be taught... in private religious schools. But religious doctrine, based on texts written millennia ago, don't have any place in the empirical, ever-adapting realms of science and the science classroom. I find it very sad that, despite every rational argument that's been made for the teaching of evolution, despite a century of scientific acceptance, and despite the fact that intelligent design/creationism/creation science has been repeatedly proven to not be a science, there's still this yearly battle over such a central fact of how the world works.
As I mentioned before, this is hardly a new problem. Anti-evolution legislation is proposed every few years, and we've discussed it before. Every time, the National Center for Science Education presents its solid stance that evolution is a science and is fundamental in understanding biology; creationism, however, is not a science and has no place in the science classroom. Normally, this is enough to prevent the bill from being passed.
It's this made-up controversy that causes around 60% of high school biology teachers to be wishy-washy, at best, with the teaching of evolution. Many of these are not creationists themselves (although, unfortunately, some are). However, it's easier to play it safe and avoid the issue than deal with unhappy parents or school boards. Less than 30% of science teachers are willing to take the necessary strong stance that evolution is a scientific fact, and deserved to be taught as the central tenant of biology that it is.
I do think that religion can be taught in schools... in a comparative religions class. Single religions can even be taught... in private religious schools. But religious doctrine, based on texts written millennia ago, don't have any place in the empirical, ever-adapting realms of science and the science classroom. I find it very sad that, despite every rational argument that's been made for the teaching of evolution, despite a century of scientific acceptance, and despite the fact that intelligent design/creationism/creation science has been repeatedly proven to not be a science, there's still this yearly battle over such a central fact of how the world works.
Posted by
Ali Marie
Religion and Politics in the Science Classroom
2011-04-13T08:20:00-05:00
Ali Marie
Basic Science|Education|Evolution|
Comments
Labels:
Basic Science,
Education,
Evolution
April 8, 2011
Storm: An Introduction to Skepticism
Tim Minchin is a fantastic comedian/musician from Australia, and a few years ago came out with a 9-minute beat poem called "Storm." Since then, over the course of two years, an animation production team has worked diligently to animate this wonderful work. It's got a very strong skeptical slant throughout, and an inspirational message at the end. Some language might not be appropriate for little kids, but past that is absolutely fantastic. Absolutely worth a watch.
Tim Minchin's Website
Storm Movie Official Website
Tim Minchin's Website
Storm Movie Official Website
Posted by
Ali Marie
Storm: An Introduction to Skepticism
2011-04-08T09:46:00-05:00
Ali Marie
Basic Science|How to Spot Pseudoscience|Medicine|Skepticism|
Comments
Labels:
Basic Science,
How to Spot Pseudoscience,
Medicine,
Skepticism
March 14, 2011
3.14159265358979323...
Today is March 14, or, as it's better known to mathematics enthusiasts, Pi Day!
Pi (π) is one of the most important constants in geometry and advanced mathematics. It stands for the ratio of a circle's circumference to its diameter. This works for any circle; if you measure the circumference and the diameter, and take the ratio, it will always simplify to approximately 22/7, or 3.14159265358979323846264338327950288419716939937510...
Pi is an irrational number, and has an infinite number of non-repeating decimal places. Currently, over 1 trillion digits of pi have been calculated, but we will never reach the end. However, for most applications, 3.14 is a good enough approximation. As March 14th is abbreviated 3/14, we celebrate this handy constant.
So have a slice of pie, and a happy pi day!
To learn more about Pi, check out http://www.piday.org/.
Pi (π) is one of the most important constants in geometry and advanced mathematics. It stands for the ratio of a circle's circumference to its diameter. This works for any circle; if you measure the circumference and the diameter, and take the ratio, it will always simplify to approximately 22/7, or 3.14159265358979323846264338327950288419716939937510...
Pi is an irrational number, and has an infinite number of non-repeating decimal places. Currently, over 1 trillion digits of pi have been calculated, but we will never reach the end. However, for most applications, 3.14 is a good enough approximation. As March 14th is abbreviated 3/14, we celebrate this handy constant.
So have a slice of pie, and a happy pi day!
To learn more about Pi, check out http://www.piday.org/.
February 12, 2011
Happy Darwin Day!
There have been a few ideas, through history, that completely revolutionize how we think about the world and jump start a long path of scientific inquiry: Copernicus' heliocentric model of the solar system and Newton's laws of motion and gravitation are two striking examples. These provide a fundamental base for modern astronomy and physics. 152 years ago, a book was published that presented a similar fundamental base for all of biology. This book was titled On the Origin of Species, and it was the first to present the idea of evolution by natural selection. Every field remotely related to biology - ecology, genetics, paleontology, medicine, and more - provides evidence for and is influenced by this the fact of evolution. Today would be the 202nd birthday of its author, Charles Darwin. So, to honor the man and celebrate his idea, have a slice of Darwin cake and look around you at the incredible diversity of life on this planet.
There's a lot of opposition to evolution in the general public, which is an issue I deal with frequently and will likely discuss in more detail in the future. For now, though, I want to leave you with a sense of how beautiful and incredible our planet is, and how much more so considering every living thing we see came from a simple prokaryote 3.8 billion years ago.
If you're interested in reading Darwin's works, they are available as open source documents at Darwin Online.
Credit to Ben of the UChicago Secular Student Alliance for making the awesome Darwin cake.
There's a lot of opposition to evolution in the general public, which is an issue I deal with frequently and will likely discuss in more detail in the future. For now, though, I want to leave you with a sense of how beautiful and incredible our planet is, and how much more so considering every living thing we see came from a simple prokaryote 3.8 billion years ago.
If you're interested in reading Darwin's works, they are available as open source documents at Darwin Online.
Credit to Ben of the UChicago Secular Student Alliance for making the awesome Darwin cake.
Posted by
Ali Marie
Happy Darwin Day!
2011-02-12T13:11:00-06:00
Ali Marie
Basic Science|Evolution|Other|
Comments
Labels:
Basic Science,
Evolution,
Other
April 27, 2010
The Language of Science: Part II
In my last post, I talked about how scientists can sometimes use overly technical jargon that confuses non-scientists. This time I wanted to talk about something about scientific speech that doesn't so much confuse people, as it is overlooked: the use of qualifiers. To pull some examples of how scientists use qualifiers, I went over to ScienceDaily.com for quotes of scientists talking about their work. I found lots of statements including these three. (italics and bold added by me)
The other thing to notice is the specificity the scientists use. The third quote is the best example of this. Dr. Turner clearly states the conditions necessary for their observations to hold true. The reason for this is twofold. The first is that any result in science should be replicable. By stating the exact conditions under which you made your observations, it makes it much easier for other researchers to confirm. The second reason comes back to what I was saying before about qualifying your statements. Imagine if Dr. Turner had said something like, 'We found that Himalayan snowfall can be used to predict Indian weather patterns.' That is so open to interpretation that it would be heavily criticized by other researchers and gives us almost no useful knowledge.
The way scientists talk is different from most people's everyday language, but for good reason. In our everyday language, we usually don't care if we leave statements a little vague or overreaching. In science, however, this is considered sloppy work. Finding examples of this is really easy because this type of language is almost taken for granted in science. Science is in some sense an enterprise of making claims. Wouldn't it be nice if claims were as clear as those made by scientists?
"To our knowledge, this is the first solid evidence that microRNAs can move from one cell to another," said Philip Benfey, director of the Duke IGSP Center for Systems Biology
"Our study adds to a growing body of literature indicating that even anthropogenic habitat modifications that does not destroy a large amount of habitat can create significant barriers to gene flow," said researchers.
Dr Andy Turner, lead author of the research, says "Our work shows how, in the absence of a strong influence from the tropical Pacific, snow conditions over the Himalayas and Tibetan Plateau could be used to help forecast seasonal monsoon rainfall for India, particularly over northern India during the onset month of June."Notice in all three cases the scientists are careful not to claim to be the final word on the issue. It is actually quite rare to read a science article, and not see words like 'indicates,' 'suggests,' or 'supports.' This is just part of science. Every researcher knows that there is a entire community who will rip apart their work if they can. Using absolutes in your language will open you up to criticism for exaggerating your results, and overplaying your work (and rightfully so). This is one thing I find so refreshing when talking with scientists. They are up-front about the strengths and weaknesses of their claims.
The other thing to notice is the specificity the scientists use. The third quote is the best example of this. Dr. Turner clearly states the conditions necessary for their observations to hold true. The reason for this is twofold. The first is that any result in science should be replicable. By stating the exact conditions under which you made your observations, it makes it much easier for other researchers to confirm. The second reason comes back to what I was saying before about qualifying your statements. Imagine if Dr. Turner had said something like, 'We found that Himalayan snowfall can be used to predict Indian weather patterns.' That is so open to interpretation that it would be heavily criticized by other researchers and gives us almost no useful knowledge.
The way scientists talk is different from most people's everyday language, but for good reason. In our everyday language, we usually don't care if we leave statements a little vague or overreaching. In science, however, this is considered sloppy work. Finding examples of this is really easy because this type of language is almost taken for granted in science. Science is in some sense an enterprise of making claims. Wouldn't it be nice if claims were as clear as those made by scientists?
Posted by
Anonymous
The Language of Science: Part II
2010-04-27T08:48:00-05:00
Anonymous
Basic Science|Language|What is Science?|
Comments
Labels:
Basic Science,
Language,
What is Science?
March 10, 2010
Expanding Earth "Theory": Going Against All Science
![]() |
| The proposed growth of the earth going from bottom to top and showing both hemispheres. Image Credit: Michael Netzer |
First, some quick background. From my research, expanding earth "theory" was first purposed in the late 1800's to explain the features and characteristics of the various continents (like how Africa and South America fit together). At the time, the idea was not well accepted, but was not considered crazy. This was still a few decades before Alfred Wegener purposed his idea of plate tectonics. Over time, we have gained an increasing understanding of how the earth works, to the point where plate tectonics is more or less a fact. In the last century, all of the new evidence has supported Wegener's theory, but some people are still trying to hang on to this failed idea.
As I mentioned before, if I tried to take their claims apart one by one this would quickly turn from a blog post into a book. Instead, I want to focus on some of the clues that should make you wonder if someone's ideas are based in reality.
The first big red flag is their dismissal of the scientific consensus. Could the scientific consensus be wrong? Sure. Saying that, though, we need to keep in mind that a scientific consensus is not something that is formed by a few guys at a bar. Many researchers, all trying to prove their own ideas over many years, work to see what model the evidence fits. Only after all this, and a repeated hashing of the evidence, is any consensus achieved. This happened very recently with the debate over what killed the dinosaurs. To think that you know better than the hundreds of geologists who study this stuff for a living, is simply arrogant. Neal Adams, maybe the most famous proponent of expanding earth theory, says that if he is right, "Everything, everything in science must change." At some point, as non-scientists, we have to step back as ask what is more plausible; that a loud comic book artist has come up with a revolutionary theory that does change all of science, or that the thousands of expert scientists worldwide understand their disciplines and the evidence for their models.
The other big clue is the use of what I have heard called "techno-babble." True scientists and science educators will often use a large vocabulary to try and explain confusing concepts. They use this vocabulary however, to try and be precise in their meaning. Scientific ideas can be inherently complex, so in explaining them the goal is to make them simpler. Proponents of non-scientific ideas will sometimes do the opposite. They will take a simple idea, and use complex language to explain it to make it sound more scientific. A perfect example of this can be found at www.expanding-earth.org. Near the bottom of the page there is a "Diagram of Omnidirectional Gravitational Pressure on exact center of any spherical body." This is a really complex way of saying, gravity pushes everything towards the center of mass. If the language is unnecessarily complex, it may be because they are trying to muddle a point instead of explaining it.
I recommend to anyone who wants to get experience looking into claims like this, look at these sites. See if you can find the flawed reasoning behind each argument. What evidence are they leaving out? If you have questions about a specific claim they are making, let us know and we can help you. We shouldn't just dismiss these ideas because they don't sound right or are unfamiliar. If we are going to dismiss them, it needs to be because there is no scientific support. In the end, nonsense dressed up with nice animations and fancy rhetoric, is still simply nonsense.
If you want to understand this issue better, I recommend you read the debate between Neal Adams and Stephen Novella, published at Neurologica.
*I cringe at the thought of calling it a theory in the scientific sense, and so found the quotation marks necessary.
Posted by
Anonymous
Expanding Earth "Theory": Going Against All Science
2010-03-10T08:32:00-06:00
Anonymous
Basic Science|Geology|How to Spot Pseudoscience|Skepticism|
Comments
Labels:
Basic Science,
Geology,
How to Spot Pseudoscience,
Skepticism
February 26, 2010
What is Science? A Musical Take
Recently, there's being a series of autotuned videos going around. While autotuning isn't all that new, these are unique because they are made up of clips of various scientists and skeptics speaking about what they know best: science. A new one was just released, titled "The Poetry of Reality." It addresses the same question we often tackle here at Scientifica Phenomena. It's beautifully done, so... enjoy.
The other videos, if you're interested, can be found at Symphony of Science.
Posted by
Ali Marie
What is Science? A Musical Take
2010-02-26T15:47:00-06:00
Ali Marie
Basic Science|Other|What is Science?|
Comments
Labels:
Basic Science,
Other,
What is Science?
February 25, 2010
Practical Science: Spectroscopy
A few times in the past I have written about how astronomers use light in various ways to learn about objects millions of miles away. Spectroscopy is simply one of the fundamentals of astronomy, but the other day I had someone ask me what the more everyday uses for spectroscopy are. Why is spectroscopy important to the everyday person? As we sat and talked, we came up with more and more ways it's used.
Spectroscopy is the study of light. In astronomy, we use it to find everything from composition, to temperature, to velocity, to extrasolar planets, and the list goes on. But how does this affect us? One of the first things that came to mind was communication. Our cell phones use radio waves to communicate with cell towers. These are the same radio waves we use to study the earliest moments of the universe. The microwaves that we use to cook our food are also part of the radio spectrum.
Healthcare is another area where examples are plentiful. X-rays and CT scans are both used in hospitals on a regular basis. They are also used to help us understand some of the most energetic places in the universe. You can get a sunburn because of ultraviolet light that penetrates our atmosphere. This same form of light gives us insight into the structure of the clouds of Venus.
Gamma rays are the highest energy form of light and are used by geologists to find minerals or other materials under the earths surface. Infrared, a much lower energy form of light, is used by weather satellites to help us know the forecast tomorrow.
All of these technologies are things we have come to rely on, and none of them would be possible without this obscure part of physics.
Spectroscopy is the study of light. In astronomy, we use it to find everything from composition, to temperature, to velocity, to extrasolar planets, and the list goes on. But how does this affect us? One of the first things that came to mind was communication. Our cell phones use radio waves to communicate with cell towers. These are the same radio waves we use to study the earliest moments of the universe. The microwaves that we use to cook our food are also part of the radio spectrum.
Healthcare is another area where examples are plentiful. X-rays and CT scans are both used in hospitals on a regular basis. They are also used to help us understand some of the most energetic places in the universe. You can get a sunburn because of ultraviolet light that penetrates our atmosphere. This same form of light gives us insight into the structure of the clouds of Venus.
Gamma rays are the highest energy form of light and are used by geologists to find minerals or other materials under the earths surface. Infrared, a much lower energy form of light, is used by weather satellites to help us know the forecast tomorrow.
All of these technologies are things we have come to rely on, and none of them would be possible without this obscure part of physics.
Posted by
Anonymous
Practical Science: Spectroscopy
2010-02-25T08:25:00-06:00
Anonymous
Basic Science|Earth and Environmental Science|Medicine|Physics|Practical Science|Space|Technology|Weather|
Comments
Labels:
Basic Science,
Earth and Environmental Science,
Medicine,
Physics,
Practical Science,
Space,
Technology,
Weather
February 22, 2010
What is Science? (Flaws of the Mind)
One of things that is of great interest to scientists and skeptics alike is how we fool ourselves. We like to think of our mind as a type of recorder that takes in what we experience and feel. In many ways, this is not a bad analogy, but it is easy for us fall victim to the faults of this recorder. These are faults that we need to be aware of if we want to avoid them
If you ever have any doubts that our minds can be fooled, see a magic trick. The entire profession of magic and illusion takes advantage of these faults. This video by psychologist Richard Wiseman is a great example.
This video is a great example of how easy it is for our brains to fall prey to illusions. This could be the cause of many UFO and ghost sightings. Think of times in your own life where you might have thought you saw something, but it turned out to be something else.
Science is very aware of this fact, this is why there are standards for the evidence it will accept. Anecdotal evidence is the most obviously affected, and is not considered any more than a starting point for scientific inquiry. One method that is used for correcting this is the requirement that a test be repeatable. For any result you come up with, someone halfway around the world should be able to repeat under the same conditions. Paranormal researchers often complain that they are being picked on by mainstream researchers. There is a lot that goes into this, deserving a post all to its own. The bottom line is that they have never developed a replicable experiment, showing any psychic ability or connection of any kind.
Whenever we look at the world, we need to be careful when deciding what is true. This doesn't mean that we can't trust anything we see, but we need to give any sight that appears miraculous careful consideration. The fact that our minds can be tricked is something we must be careful never to forget, but we shouldn't let it stop us in our quest to explore reality.
If you ever have any doubts that our minds can be fooled, see a magic trick. The entire profession of magic and illusion takes advantage of these faults. This video by psychologist Richard Wiseman is a great example.
This video is a great example of how easy it is for our brains to fall prey to illusions. This could be the cause of many UFO and ghost sightings. Think of times in your own life where you might have thought you saw something, but it turned out to be something else.
Science is very aware of this fact, this is why there are standards for the evidence it will accept. Anecdotal evidence is the most obviously affected, and is not considered any more than a starting point for scientific inquiry. One method that is used for correcting this is the requirement that a test be repeatable. For any result you come up with, someone halfway around the world should be able to repeat under the same conditions. Paranormal researchers often complain that they are being picked on by mainstream researchers. There is a lot that goes into this, deserving a post all to its own. The bottom line is that they have never developed a replicable experiment, showing any psychic ability or connection of any kind.
Whenever we look at the world, we need to be careful when deciding what is true. This doesn't mean that we can't trust anything we see, but we need to give any sight that appears miraculous careful consideration. The fact that our minds can be tricked is something we must be careful never to forget, but we shouldn't let it stop us in our quest to explore reality.
Posted by
Anonymous
What is Science? (Flaws of the Mind)
2010-02-22T08:33:00-06:00
Anonymous
Basic Science|Scientific Process|Skepticism|
Comments
Labels:
Basic Science,
Scientific Process,
Skepticism
February 17, 2010
Dynamic Earth: Introduction to Weather
Where I grew up, there was a common saying regarding the weather: "If you don't like it, wait a few minutes. It will change." While not precisely true, it did seem that the weather changed quite a lot. It could be snowing in the morning and 65 and sunny by the afternoon. We've all experienced many forms of weather, and so have a general understanding of what it is. However, there are more precise ways to define the weather.
What is weather?
Weather is defined by meteorologists as the state of the atmosphere at a given point in time. Typically, they are only referring to the troposphere, the lowest layer of the atmosphere. The weather is determined by 7 main factors: air temperature, air pressure, cloud type, precipitation type, precipitation amount, wind speed, and wind direction. As an example, the full weather report of where I live right now is: 29.8o F; 30.02 in pressure; cumulus clouds; light snow; up to 2 in; 1.0 mph winds, from the south-east.
Weather vs. Climate
Weather is not the same thing as climate. This is a really common misconception with all the news about "global warming" and "climate change." Weather is local and short term. It is snowing here right now, but it was sunny yesterday. Also, it's probably not snowing all over the Midwest, just here. Climate, on the other hand, is long-term and broad, covering regions to the entire planet. Thus, on average, over much of the planet, annual temperatures over the past 100 years have been getting warmer. A freak snowstorm does not mean climate change is not occurring, nor is it necessarily caused by climate change. The two are related, but are not directly connected. So, as much as people like to claim that this bitter cold winter disproves global warming, that's simply not how it works.
That's basically all there is to weather. It's a local set of atmospheric conditions. For sounding so simple, and even boring, however, there's a lot of unpredictability in weather, which can lead to some pretty terrifying phenomena.
More on weather.
Weather is defined by meteorologists as the state of the atmosphere at a given point in time. Typically, they are only referring to the troposphere, the lowest layer of the atmosphere. The weather is determined by 7 main factors: air temperature, air pressure, cloud type, precipitation type, precipitation amount, wind speed, and wind direction. As an example, the full weather report of where I live right now is: 29.8o F; 30.02 in pressure; cumulus clouds; light snow; up to 2 in; 1.0 mph winds, from the south-east.
Weather vs. Climate
Weather is not the same thing as climate. This is a really common misconception with all the news about "global warming" and "climate change." Weather is local and short term. It is snowing here right now, but it was sunny yesterday. Also, it's probably not snowing all over the Midwest, just here. Climate, on the other hand, is long-term and broad, covering regions to the entire planet. Thus, on average, over much of the planet, annual temperatures over the past 100 years have been getting warmer. A freak snowstorm does not mean climate change is not occurring, nor is it necessarily caused by climate change. The two are related, but are not directly connected. So, as much as people like to claim that this bitter cold winter disproves global warming, that's simply not how it works.
That's basically all there is to weather. It's a local set of atmospheric conditions. For sounding so simple, and even boring, however, there's a lot of unpredictability in weather, which can lead to some pretty terrifying phenomena.
More on weather.
Posted by
Ali Marie
Dynamic Earth: Introduction to Weather
2010-02-17T11:37:00-06:00
Ali Marie
Basic Science|Earth and Environmental Science|Weather|
Comments
February 15, 2010
Bad Science: The Argument From Final Consequences
In many of the articles I read supporting non-scientific ideas or in informal debates, one extremely common logical fallacy I run across is the argument from final consequences. I see it often enough that I think it deserves it own post so you can try to avoid this logical pitfall.
There are two main ways this fallacy is usually presented, but both share a common trait. They basically invert cause and effect. One way this is done is to say that if someone benefited from X, that person caused X. You can imagine in a murder investigation that if someone benefited highly from the death, they will be a suspect. The fallacy is to say that because they benefited, they must have caused it. Motivation is separate from actually committing the crime. There is a reality to the world that coincidences happen. Everyone, and in particular politicians, will try to capitalize on these coincidences, but that doesn't mean they caused them.
The other way this fallacy often comes up is to say the implications of an idea determine its truth. An example is 'Fairies must exist, because that would make the world more interesting.' Whether or not they would make the world more interesting is completely irrelevant to the question of their existence. This is the equivalent of arguing that gravity can't exist, because flying is fun. One of the most common contexts you will hear this agreement is that evolution must be wrong because otherwise life has no meaning and their would be no morality.
I should mention again that just because someone uses bad logic to defend their point, doesn't mean that their conclusion is wrong. All it means is that particular argument does not support that conclusion. I have heard people on both sides of different issues make poor logical arguments, so you need to evaluate each argument on its own merits. Bad logic should however, serve as a red flag to see if any of their other arguments hold up to strong scrutiny.
There are two main ways this fallacy is usually presented, but both share a common trait. They basically invert cause and effect. One way this is done is to say that if someone benefited from X, that person caused X. You can imagine in a murder investigation that if someone benefited highly from the death, they will be a suspect. The fallacy is to say that because they benefited, they must have caused it. Motivation is separate from actually committing the crime. There is a reality to the world that coincidences happen. Everyone, and in particular politicians, will try to capitalize on these coincidences, but that doesn't mean they caused them.
The other way this fallacy often comes up is to say the implications of an idea determine its truth. An example is 'Fairies must exist, because that would make the world more interesting.' Whether or not they would make the world more interesting is completely irrelevant to the question of their existence. This is the equivalent of arguing that gravity can't exist, because flying is fun. One of the most common contexts you will hear this agreement is that evolution must be wrong because otherwise life has no meaning and their would be no morality.
I should mention again that just because someone uses bad logic to defend their point, doesn't mean that their conclusion is wrong. All it means is that particular argument does not support that conclusion. I have heard people on both sides of different issues make poor logical arguments, so you need to evaluate each argument on its own merits. Bad logic should however, serve as a red flag to see if any of their other arguments hold up to strong scrutiny.
Posted by
Anonymous
Bad Science: The Argument From Final Consequences
2010-02-15T08:01:00-06:00
Anonymous
Basic Science|How to Spot Pseudoscience|Scientific Process|Skepticism|
Comments
January 20, 2010
Puppies for Evolution
Most of us are familiar primarily with domesticated animals. They are food, pack animals, and pets. Dogs are one of the species that was domesticated relatively early, and now numerous breeds of dog exist, to fit pretty much every taste. Domestication has an interesting interplay with evolution. Far from reducing the pressures on a species, it can create new ones, leading to some pretty profound changes.
Before we can look at that, though, we have to understand how evolution works. Evolution, in its most basic form, is the process by which species change over time. Its driving mechanism is natural selection, or "survival of the fittest." In a given group of individuals, there are going to be differences. Some of these differences help an individual; others give it a disadvantage; most don't do anything at all. A great example of this is the peppered moth of England. Some individuals were a light color, matching the bark on the lichen trees where the moths live. Others were a sooty gray. Before the Industrial Revolution, the dark moths were pretty rare; birds could see and eat them pretty easily. During and afterwards, however, the soot on the trees gave the dark moths the advantage, and the light moths became rare. Now, as the pollution levels have fallen, the light moths are making a comeback. It's the classic example of natural selection in action.
Now, I'm sure by this point you're trying to figure out why I started with puppies when I was just going to talk about moths. I'm getting back to puppies now. A new study suggests that selection is well at work in domestic dogs, to an extent that doesn't occur in nature. This is artificial selection, rather than natural selection. See, domestic dogs don't face the same pressures as their cousins, wolves and coyotes.
They don't have to chase down live prey and eat tough, raw meat. There is no shortage of easily accessible food, water, and shelter. Therefore, domestic dogs aren't playing the game of "survival of the fittest;" rather, they are playing "survival of the cutest." The study specifically looked at skull shapes of various carnivores, including several breeds of domestic dog. The results are impressive: it turns out a cat and a walrus have more in common, head-shape wise, than a collie does with a Pekingese. Because people are the main pressure selecting for characteristics, rather than practicality, a breed like a pug can survive as a pet. In the wild, a pug would be unable to breathe, eat, or avoid anything that wanted to eat it. Cute? Maybe. Practical? No.
The pressures on dogs, and other domestic organisms, are an interesting study in evolution. Freed from the very limiting pressures of natural selection, these creatures can develop characteristics that would be totally impractical in the wild. From this diversity, humans pick the characteristics they like best, and breed those specifically, while other characteristics are deemed ugly, and are selected against. The process is fast, and easy to observe. This artificial selection is a proof-of-concept experiment for natural selection and the Darwinian model of evolution.
Source: Science Daily- "'Survival of the Cutest' Proves Darwin Right"
Charles Darwin's On the Origin of Species: A Graphic Adaptation, Michael Keller (Amazon)
The pressures on dogs, and other domestic organisms, are an interesting study in evolution. Freed from the very limiting pressures of natural selection, these creatures can develop characteristics that would be totally impractical in the wild. From this diversity, humans pick the characteristics they like best, and breed those specifically, while other characteristics are deemed ugly, and are selected against. The process is fast, and easy to observe. This artificial selection is a proof-of-concept experiment for natural selection and the Darwinian model of evolution.
Source: Science Daily- "'Survival of the Cutest' Proves Darwin Right"
Charles Darwin's On the Origin of Species: A Graphic Adaptation, Michael Keller (Amazon)
Posted by
Ali Marie
Puppies for Evolution
2010-01-20T15:17:00-06:00
Ali Marie
Basic Science|Earth and Environmental Science|Evolution|
Comments
December 14, 2009
What is Science? (Using Unknowns to Prove a Point)
Carl Sagan famously said, “Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence." On the flip side, proponents of a nonscientific idea will sometimes invoke a lack of evidence as proof of something. Evidence is a tricky thing, and a lack of evidence can easily fool many people.
A absence of evidence is often cited in the debate regarding the existence of other life in the universe. We have never received signals from ET and, while there have been tantalizing hints of life on Mars, nothing has even come close to being confirmed. So with no evidence, are we forced to just admit that we are the only lifeforms in the universe? No, we have just begun to scratch the surface of looking for life beyond the Earth. Just because we don't have evidence yet doesn't mean we won't find it.
This idea can be taken too far. Just as we have a absence of evidence for life on other worlds, we also have a absence of evidence for unicorns. It is logically impossible to prove a negative (like unicorns don't exist) so are we forced to accept them as equal possibilites? In science, we can assess the plausibility of a claim. It is highly plausible that there is life outside the Earth that we have yet to find considering how little of the universe we have explored. We have however, explored a vast majority of the land mass of the Earth and have yet to find unicorns. While there is nothing intrinsically impossible about a horse evolving a horn, we just haven't found it in our explorations. So, while a absence of evidence may not be evidence of absence, we can still use current knowledge to judge the likelihood of different claims.
The other way people try to use the gaps in our knowledge is to prove claims. This is known as the argument from ignorance. In my experience, this is one of the most common logical fallacies. The basic argument goes because we don't understand X, Y is true. This is often invoked with quantum mechanics. People will make arguments to the effect that because we don't understand the quantum world, psychics really have powers. The same argument could have been used only a few centuries ago to say because we don't understand flight, humans can fly by flapping their arms. You can't use our lack of understanding to prove anything.
It is not hard to find people on the internet and in real life committing both forms of this flawed logic. Whenever you encounter a claim, make sure you ask yourself if they are using unknowns to make their arguments. Are they asserting someone is true because we don't understand something? When it comes down to it, a lack of evidence is evidence for nothing.
Posted by
Anonymous
What is Science? (Using Unknowns to Prove a Point)
2009-12-14T08:47:00-06:00
Anonymous
Basic Science|Scientific Process|Skepticism|What is Science?|
Comments
August 20, 2009
What is Skepticism?
Science is a process. We use this process the understand the natural world around us. There is a growing group of people who use this process to form their opinions about the world. Skeptics promote critical thinking and science education. Skeptics do not just dismiss ideas out of hand, but try to establish if an idea is supported by the evidence. Skepticism is not a set of beliefs, but a method. There are issues that multiple reasonable skeptics will hold different opinions on.
Skeptics often rely on the scientific method because it is one that relies on evidence and logic. In science, anecdotal evidence is below the standard of evidence. This is one of the main reasons that skeptics can often get branded as deniers. Skeptics will often reject ideas like UFOs and ghosts because the evidence does not support them. This, however, can lead to the false conclusion that skeptics are close-minded.
Skeptics, as a group, have to remain open-minded. To be close-minded is to hold a set of beliefs regardless of new evidence. The evidence we have about the world around us always changing. Since skepticism is based on evidence, our stances on different issues have to change.
Skepticism is a powerful tool for exploring reality. There are many cases where a dose of skepticism can really help in everyday life. Skepticism is a way to keep an open mind and still be able to filter out the nonsense.
Posted by
Anonymous
What is Skepticism?
2009-08-20T15:58:00-05:00
Anonymous
Basic Science|Skepticism|
Comments
Labels:
Basic Science,
Skepticism
August 19, 2009
Scientific Unknowns: What is Life?
Life is you, me, and every living thing on our planet, but defining it nearly impossible. We study life here on Earth and look for it on distant worlds, so how can we not know what it is? The real problem is we only have one example of life: our planet.
All life on Earth is based on the same things. Carbon makes up the organic molecules; think of these as the Lego set of life. DNA is the code that allows for replication and therefore evolution. Water is the liquid that allows the organics to easily form long chains. All of these things have come together to make life here on Earth. What we don't know is if life could be based on other things, for example, liquid methane instead of liquid water.
Imagine that you had to define what a dog is, with only a St. Bernard as your example. A St. Bernard has four legs, slobbers all over, is very resilient to the cold, has a long snout, and is usually very friendly. By making a definition of all dogs by one breed, your definition becomes biased towards that breed. Some things like having four legs will apply to all dogs, but when you try to pin down specific attributes your definition breaks down fast.
So, what parts of our definition of life apply across the board, and when are we being too specific? We don't know. This is maybe one of the most important questions in science, because it directly relates to how we look for other forms of life in the universe. Could life be based on something other than carbon, maybe sulfur or silicon? Is there a code other than DNA that life on a distant world has utilized? The universe has always found ways of surprising us wherever we look. I see no reason why the search for life would be any different.
All life on Earth is based on the same things. Carbon makes up the organic molecules; think of these as the Lego set of life. DNA is the code that allows for replication and therefore evolution. Water is the liquid that allows the organics to easily form long chains. All of these things have come together to make life here on Earth. What we don't know is if life could be based on other things, for example, liquid methane instead of liquid water.
Imagine that you had to define what a dog is, with only a St. Bernard as your example. A St. Bernard has four legs, slobbers all over, is very resilient to the cold, has a long snout, and is usually very friendly. By making a definition of all dogs by one breed, your definition becomes biased towards that breed. Some things like having four legs will apply to all dogs, but when you try to pin down specific attributes your definition breaks down fast.
So, what parts of our definition of life apply across the board, and when are we being too specific? We don't know. This is maybe one of the most important questions in science, because it directly relates to how we look for other forms of life in the universe. Could life be based on something other than carbon, maybe sulfur or silicon? Is there a code other than DNA that life on a distant world has utilized? The universe has always found ways of surprising us wherever we look. I see no reason why the search for life would be any different.
Posted by
Anonymous
Scientific Unknowns: What is Life?
2009-08-19T14:22:00-05:00
Anonymous
Basic Science|Scientific Unknowns|
Comments
Labels:
Basic Science,
Scientific Unknowns
August 17, 2009
The Wonder of Science
The night sky is a beautiful thing. I don't think I will ever get tired of seeing the Milky Way, or a meteor flash across the sky. Even the simple twinkle of a star. Yes, we live in an amazing universe. I think so many undervalue the beauty of nature, because they haven't been shown its complexity. Science is a method of describing reality. The reality of the universe, our universe, is one of unimaginable wonder and splendor.
I think that by destroying the quality of science education, we create the perfect storm for those who promote pseudoscience. We all want to think of our universe as a incredible place to live. I think that this is part of being human. If we starve a generation of the wonders of science, they will try to find it elsewhere. As much as the ideas of pseudoscientists may resonate within a person, it is the products of science that resonate with the world.
Science may not always give us the answer we want, but the answers we get are often stranger and more intricate then anyone would have ever guessed. We have never found evidence of Thor, but we have found black holes. Psychics have yet to show that they can see into the future, but scientists see billions of years into the past. We may not have found Bigfoot, but what of the dinosaurs that would make even a Yeti tremble? We have found particles that break all our common knowledge, and galaxies that break our sense of scale. No, the answers that science gives us are not always in line with what we want. The answers are rarely simple, and maybe not as comforting as we may like. Still, it is science in which I trust.
I write this now on the keyboard of my computer. As I do so, I draw electricity from my battery. That electricity was produced far from where I sit now, yet I am able to use it. You are able to read my words, because I have broadcast them through the air in a form of light invisible to my eyes. From there, the signal took advantage of cables, a work of art in and of themselves. I am sure before it ever reached you, it has been converted back and forth many times. It has done so while maintaining the quality necessary for you to be able to see these words in front of you. This is what science has done for us.
If somehow this does not impress you, think of this. If we were to live at almost any other point in history, we would not be able to come even close to feeding 6 billion people. Science makes this possible. Until very recently, people lived to a average age of 40. Now many of us expect to live to 80 or beyond. Science has changed the world in a way that I find unrivaled by any other human endeavor.
Today, I have watched the skies, but I have done so with friends. I have climbed mountains and looked out over amazing vistas. I have seen wonder in not only the eyes of a child, but in the eyes of high schoolers. I have met people whose lives I can only imagine. I have talked to the disabled, the elderly, and every other group I can think of. Regardless of who they were, or what they had done, there was something that they all shared. The curiosity and amazement I could see in them as they held a simple meteorite. It is amazing what a little rock from space can do.
This is why I explore the world. This is why I use science. The songwriter and comedian Tim Minchin said something in one of this poems that I think really sums up things very nicely. “Life is full of mysteries, yeah , but there are answers out there and they won’t be found by people sitting around looking serious and saying 'Isn’t life mysterious?' ”
I think that by destroying the quality of science education, we create the perfect storm for those who promote pseudoscience. We all want to think of our universe as a incredible place to live. I think that this is part of being human. If we starve a generation of the wonders of science, they will try to find it elsewhere. As much as the ideas of pseudoscientists may resonate within a person, it is the products of science that resonate with the world.
Science may not always give us the answer we want, but the answers we get are often stranger and more intricate then anyone would have ever guessed. We have never found evidence of Thor, but we have found black holes. Psychics have yet to show that they can see into the future, but scientists see billions of years into the past. We may not have found Bigfoot, but what of the dinosaurs that would make even a Yeti tremble? We have found particles that break all our common knowledge, and galaxies that break our sense of scale. No, the answers that science gives us are not always in line with what we want. The answers are rarely simple, and maybe not as comforting as we may like. Still, it is science in which I trust.
I write this now on the keyboard of my computer. As I do so, I draw electricity from my battery. That electricity was produced far from where I sit now, yet I am able to use it. You are able to read my words, because I have broadcast them through the air in a form of light invisible to my eyes. From there, the signal took advantage of cables, a work of art in and of themselves. I am sure before it ever reached you, it has been converted back and forth many times. It has done so while maintaining the quality necessary for you to be able to see these words in front of you. This is what science has done for us.
If somehow this does not impress you, think of this. If we were to live at almost any other point in history, we would not be able to come even close to feeding 6 billion people. Science makes this possible. Until very recently, people lived to a average age of 40. Now many of us expect to live to 80 or beyond. Science has changed the world in a way that I find unrivaled by any other human endeavor.
Today, I have watched the skies, but I have done so with friends. I have climbed mountains and looked out over amazing vistas. I have seen wonder in not only the eyes of a child, but in the eyes of high schoolers. I have met people whose lives I can only imagine. I have talked to the disabled, the elderly, and every other group I can think of. Regardless of who they were, or what they had done, there was something that they all shared. The curiosity and amazement I could see in them as they held a simple meteorite. It is amazing what a little rock from space can do.
This is why I explore the world. This is why I use science. The songwriter and comedian Tim Minchin said something in one of this poems that I think really sums up things very nicely. “Life is full of mysteries, yeah , but there are answers out there and they won’t be found by people sitting around looking serious and saying 'Isn’t life mysterious?' ”
Posted by
Anonymous
The Wonder of Science
2009-08-17T15:20:00-05:00
Anonymous
Basic Science|Skepticism|What is Science?|
Comments
Labels:
Basic Science,
Skepticism,
What is Science?
Bad Science: Pareidolia
There are many ways that we can come to believe in an idea. Sometimes we even think that we are acting on evidence, when in reality that evidence is fallacious. This Bad Science series is going to point out some common ways our brains can be tricked.
To start with, I have chosen one of my favorites: pareidolia. Think of this as seeing familiar images in the clouds. Our brains are really good at finding patterns. That's why you can look at the bark of a tree or a rock formation and see a face. Once you see that face, it may be hard not to see it. This can make for a fun optical illusion. The problem is when people think that the face in the clouds is real.
One of the best and most famous pieces of pareidolia is the face on Mars. You can clearly see in this 1976 voyager picture a face in the rocks (left, near the top of the image). The face is actually the product of shadows cast by the sun, poor resolution, and pareidolia. When this was released it was used to fuel a conspiracy theory of an aliens on Mars.
In 2001, NASA put any questions to rest regarding this weird formation. The Mars Global Surveyor took a high resolution picture of the same formation when the sun was at a different angle (below). I can still kinda make out where the eye and nose is, but it clearly just a rock formation.
Pareidolia is something we all experience. It is literally hard-wired into our brains. We can even experience audio pareidolia. Our brains are amazing things, but we always need to remember that they can be fooled. Sometimes clouds are just clouds, rocks are just rocks, and shadows are just shadows. Enjoy the photos, but be skeptical.
For more see the Skeptics Dictionary
Images courtesy NASA
To start with, I have chosen one of my favorites: pareidolia. Think of this as seeing familiar images in the clouds. Our brains are really good at finding patterns. That's why you can look at the bark of a tree or a rock formation and see a face. Once you see that face, it may be hard not to see it. This can make for a fun optical illusion. The problem is when people think that the face in the clouds is real.
One of the best and most famous pieces of pareidolia is the face on Mars. You can clearly see in this 1976 voyager picture a face in the rocks (left, near the top of the image). The face is actually the product of shadows cast by the sun, poor resolution, and pareidolia. When this was released it was used to fuel a conspiracy theory of an aliens on Mars.
In 2001, NASA put any questions to rest regarding this weird formation. The Mars Global Surveyor took a high resolution picture of the same formation when the sun was at a different angle (below). I can still kinda make out where the eye and nose is, but it clearly just a rock formation.
Pareidolia is something we all experience. It is literally hard-wired into our brains. We can even experience audio pareidolia. Our brains are amazing things, but we always need to remember that they can be fooled. Sometimes clouds are just clouds, rocks are just rocks, and shadows are just shadows. Enjoy the photos, but be skeptical.
For more see the Skeptics Dictionary
Images courtesy NASA
Posted by
Anonymous
Bad Science: Pareidolia
2009-08-17T11:00:00-05:00
Anonymous
Basic Science|Mars|Skepticism|
Comments
Labels:
Basic Science,
Mars,
Skepticism
August 4, 2009
POP: Preparation
From out in the field, the next step is actually getting the fossils prepared for research or display. There are a lot of different techniques for preparation, depending on what type of fossil is being worked on.
Leaves and Invertebrates
Leaf fossils and invertebrates are often not removed fully from the rock, as they are too fragile. Instead, small air scribes are used to carefully remove rock from around the fossil. This reveals intricate structures in the fossils: veination in leaves, stripes on insects, spines on trilobites.
For more information, visit the DMNS Follow a Fossil site, and read the preparation section.
Image credit: Marc Behrendt Preparation
Leaves and Invertebrates
Leaf fossils and invertebrates are often not removed fully from the rock, as they are too fragile. Instead, small air scribes are used to carefully remove rock from around the fossil. This reveals intricate structures in the fossils: veination in leaves, stripes on insects, spines on trilobites.
Sometimes, acids and other chemicals are used to prepare the fossils as well. This technique has to be very delicate, however, so as not to errode the fossils along with the rocks.
Fossil cystoids, before and after preparation
Vertebrates
Most vertebrates are prepared out of the rocks entirely, though not all. Fish fossils, particularly, are often left in the matrix, as was the famous Archaeopteryx specimen. Small air scribes, dental picks, water, acetone glues, and a lot of patience are generally the tools of choice. Preparators have to work slowly, so as not to damage the bone. In fact, it takes about 300-500% more time to prepare a fossil than it does to take it out of the field in the first place. Every bit of exposed bone has to be carefully reinforced with superglues, as well, so it doesn't crumble away. It's a tedious process, but a necessary one. Without preparation, not one fossil could be studied or put on display in a museum.
A saber-toothed cat skull, before and after preparation
For more information, visit the DMNS Follow a Fossil site, and read the preparation section.
Image credit: Marc Behrendt Preparation
Posted by
Ali Marie
POP: Preparation
2009-08-04T12:04:00-05:00
Ali Marie
Basic Science|Earth and Environmental Science|Geology|Paleontology|Scientific Process|
Comments
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






